A university is just a group of buildings gathered around a library. ~Shelby Foote

Saturday, October 01, 2005

BIAS 101

Sometimes the media bias is hit you over the head and is in your face-- as with the treatment of Bill Bennett, who said something very poorly, live on the radio, but who is not advocating the aborting of all black people. Indeed, Bennett is philosophically opposed to any and all abortions. Yet the context of Bennett's statement is lost because the media wishes to portray what he said as something other than what was intended.

And then sometimes media bias is much subtler. Denunciations of Justice Roberts by Ted Kennedy and Joe Biden get front page coverage, while words of support for Roberts by people like Russ Feingold-- anything but a neocon hack-- are buried on page 7 or the like. Where the news is located on, and within, the newpaper can be a very influential factor on whether it gets read or not. Even more subtle is to present one side of a story (usually the liberal side) in the first 5-10 paragraphs, and then present the other side later on in the piece. True, both sides are equally represented-- but most newspaper readers only read the first 5-10 paragraphs, especially when the latter parts of the article are on a different page. So one viewpoint gets far more exposure to readers than does the other.

Finally, let's go back to context-- this time in a more subtle manner than in the first example. Quite often these day, it seems that the media reports things that are true as far as they go... but they don't give you all the details you need to determine if what you have been shown is the whole truth. So, when anti-war protesters get several thousand people to show up, it's a major rally (it is), and the country is clearly turning against the war. But, if you are also told that protesters expected in excess of 100,000 people, and nearly as many folks in favor of continuing to support the Iraqis turned up in addition to the protesters, the "tide is turning" perspective isn't quite so clear cut. Especially when you add it the greater money, organization and lead time the protesters had over the counter protesters. Or, if you're the media, you can just do this.

And while you're checking out the importance of context, do check out the gallery of protest pictures. Quite interesting. Though, of course, you should bear in mind that the photographer is clearly a supporter of the war, and thus factor that bias into your reactions to the pictures.
Comments:
Bennett has been taken out of context greatly on this one. A caller to his show said that he (the caller) was against abortion because if there were more babies then there would eventually be more taxpayers, a better GDP, and a smaller deficit. Bennett told the caller that he should be careful with arguments like that because supporters of abortion (or the right to one) could make a similar argument where a child would not become a productive member of society. Bennett went on to make his quote regarding blacks having abortions and a resulting effect on crime rate, noting that it would be an impossible, ridiculous, and morally reprehensible thing to do. He then followed that up by stating that far-reaching extrapolations are ill-advised.

Bennett may have made a bad choice for his example of an opposing side arguement, but the way he has been taken out of context in no way shows the true nature of his character. He has offered to put his record up against that of Howard Dean, Harry Reid, and his other detractors, and also to debate them on the issues, but no one has taken him up on either of the offers to date.
 
If you really want to reduce crime, try killing all politicians. I'll bet the % of politicians performing criminal acts is far greater than the % of any racial group.

Scott
 
If you really want to reduce crime, try killing all politicians. I'll bet the % of politicians performing criminal acts is far greater than the % of any racial group.

You could have something there; the politicians rip-off something like 40% of my money. They take it at gunpoint; if I resist I'll be thrown into jail. They use my money as they please, with no regard to my wishes.

There is no native criminal class except Congress.
- Mark Twain
 
Post a Comment

<< Home

This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?